If you don’t want to eat the second Pop Tart, put it into a plastic bag so that it doesn’t get stale.
You can turn your toaster to a higher setting if you want your Pop Tart a little more well-done, but keep an eye on it so that it doesn’t burn.
If your toaster doesn’t have a low setting, you can set a timer for 1 minute and just take your Pop Tart out manually.
If you don’t have a microwave-safe plate, use a paper towel instead.
It may seem silly to only microwave your Pop Tart for 3 seconds, but that’s all the heat it needs!
If your plate got super hot in the microwave, use an oven mitt to grab it out so you don’t hurt your hands.
If you aren’t going to eat the second Pop Tart, seal it in a plastic bag and save it for later.
If your toaster oven has 2 racks, put your Pop Tart on the top one.
The longer your Pop Tart is in the toaster oven, the more crispy it will be.
